Google Airs Privacy Principles, Sets Itself Up for Ridicule
You can bet that any time a company such as Google announces anything having to do with its privacy, it's going to cause privacy advocates to bare their teeth. That is exactly what I imagine will happen once certain privacy watchdogs in Washington, D.C., California and perhaps even in Europe read Google's latest appeal to their clandestine sensibilities Jan. 28, which is apparently International Data Privacy Day. If only we treated all of these faux holidays the way we do nationally and internationally recognized holidays, we would be golden. But alas... To celebrate International Data Privacy Day, Google published the five core principles that inform its approach to building Web services and applications. Alan Eustace, Google's senior vice president of engineering & research, explained Google's thinking for releasing the guidelines to the public:
We've always operated with these principles in mind. Now, we're just putting them in writing so you have a better understanding of how we think about these issues from a product perspective. Like our design and software guidelines, these privacy principles are designed to guide the decisions we make when we create new technologies. This is consistent with efforts Google took in 2009 to be more transparent about how it handles user data. For example, the Data Liberation Front is a great effort to make sure users can shuttle their data to and from Google Apps. Google Dashboard shows Google Apps users where their data is and how much of it exists in YouTube, Google Docs, etc. Still, privacy critics winked, nodded and asked Google when it would spell out cookie info and Web browser history, or info related to interest-based ads. That's the info Google collects on its users that critics want displayed in Dashboard. Without further ado, here are the principles, the short and sweet version:
To get a good handle on what these rules entail in practice, you should really watch this brief video after the jump. Google explains how it uses info from our search history to disambiguate between similar queries and how it provides an off-the-record chat feature for Google Talk, among other measures.
What do you think? Is this a fine, open overture, or just a platitude for privacy buffs? |

Comments (3)
Will everyone stop punishing Google for being upfront? Do you think Bing doesn't collect so much information about you?
Posted by sam | January 28, 2010 3:57 PM
I totally agree with you sam. Other search engines and services know a bunch about you to. I personally don't care that Google knows what I search for...why should I? It's not like they're advertising to the world what Bill searches for...who cares? Google is just trying to serve better ads to me so they can make more money. Nothing wrong with that. Google is one of the most innovative companies on the planet as far as services go (free!). If all Google wants is a record of my searches, than let it be.
Posted by Bill | January 29, 2010 3:39 AM
I disagree.
Google has a huge search marketshare. The majority of all searches go through Google search engines. So I ask you:
1. you are trading privacy for better targeted ads so Google can make money. Why do you need to trade your privacy to help Google make $23.6 Billion?
2. what if Google changes their policies 5 years down the line? 10 years down the line? they still have all of your information which can easily be deanonymized.
3. if something happens to Google such that they change their policies in the future, think of this scenario. Google knows what you have searched for. They can easily correlate that with company ip addresses. They can probably even guess your role at that company. After they filter out personal searches, they have a pretty interesting picture of what anyone in your company has searched for. They can potentially guess what your company's strategy is before your company has even ironed out all the details.
If you feel Google is encroaching on your personal or corporate space, then I would urge you not to use google services.
Posted by Will | March 3, 2010 3:58 PM